Behavioral Interview Questions for Innovation Managers
By Dara Halloran · Under Pressure
What behavioral questions do innovation manager interviews ask? Expect an idea you took from nothing to a pilot, an experiment that failed, a time you killed a project, how you got a sceptical business unit to adopt something new, and how you pitched for funding. Answer with real ideas, the cheapest test you ran, what it showed, and what happened next. Show the discipline behind the creativity.
Innovation managers are hired to create new things inside organisations that are mostly built to run existing ones. Interviews for the role look for two qualities that do not always come together: the imagination to find ideas worth trying, and the discipline to test them cheaply, stop most of them, and get the survivors adopted by people who did not ask for them.
Your pitch is part of the job, and the interview
Much of an innovation manager's work is pitching: to leadership for funding, to business units for adoption, sometimes to external partners. The interview is a pitch too. There is research on what moves people hearing a pitch. Colin Clark had business angels rate live entrepreneur pitches on 32 aspects and found that the aspects about how the pitch was presented weighed most on their interest in investing, even though, when the angels explained their decisions, they talked almost entirely about the business.1
For an interview, that has two implications. Delivery matters more than candidates think, so tell your stories clearly and with energy. But the panel will justify its decision on substance, so every story needs real numbers and real outcomes behind the delivery.
Finding and testing ideas
"Tell me about an idea you took from nothing to a pilot." Where the idea came from, the first cheap test, what it showed, how you got support, and what the pilot delivered.
"Tell me about an experiment that failed." What you were testing, what you learned and how it changed the next step. Panels distrust candidates whose experiments all worked.
"How do you decide which ideas to test?" Show your criteria and a real example of an idea you chose not to pursue.
Stopping things
"Tell me about a project you killed." The evidence, how you decided, how you told the team and the sponsor, and what was kept from it.
Getting adoption
"Tell me about getting a sceptical business unit to adopt something new." The objection, how you reduced the risk for them (a small pilot, their own data, shared credit), and the result.
"Tell me about an innovation that worked technically but wasn't adopted." Why, and what you do differently now.
Money
"Tell me about pitching for funding." Who, how much, what you showed, what you got.
Questions worth asking them
Ask how innovation is funded (a central budget or business units), what happened to the last three pilots, who decides whether a pilot scales, and how failure is treated. An innovation role with no route from pilot to business adoption is a role where good work goes nowhere.
The numbers to have ready
Ideas tested, pilots run and how many scaled, the cost of your tests, the value of the ones that were adopted, and the time from idea to pilot. Panels value a low cost per test as much as the occasional large win.
One answer, told well
"Our field engineers spent about an hour a day on paperwork. I tested a voice-note app with five engineers for two weeks, at almost no cost, and measured the time saved: about forty minutes a day each. I took those numbers to the operations director, offered to run a three-month pilot in one region with his team owning the result, and he agreed. The pilot held up, and the tool went to all 300 engineers the following year."
For pitching new ideas inside an organisation, see presentation tips for product development managers, and for the structure of every answer, the STAR technique.
References
- Clark, C. (2008). The impact of entrepreneurs’ oral “pitch” presentation skills on business angels’ initial screening investment decisions. Venture Capital, 10(3), 257–279. https://doi.org/10.1080/13691060802151945