Presentation Tips for Audit Managers: Findings That Land

By Daniel Harper · Career & Business

How should an audit manager present findings? State each finding plainly with its evidence and its risk in business terms, include management’s view, and answer it rather than ignoring it. Acknowledging the other side and then responding is more persuasive than presenting only your own case. Agree actions with owners and dates, and give the audit committee the few findings that matter most.

Audit managers, internal or external, present findings to people who were not looking forward to receiving them. The closing meeting with the auditee, the report to the audit committee, the follow-up on actions that were not done: all of these involve telling capable people that something in their area is not working. The presentations that change things are the ones that leave the auditee agreeing with the finding, not just accepting it.

Present the finding with its evidence and its risk

A finding has four parts, and the presentation should cover all of them in this order:

  1. What we found. The condition, plainly stated.
  2. The evidence. What we tested, the sample, the exceptions.
  3. Why it matters. The risk in business terms: money, customers, regulators, fraud, reputation.
  4. What we recommend.

A finding without the third part reads as a rule being enforced for its own sake. With it, the auditee can see why it matters to them.

Include management's view, and answer it

The most common reason audit findings meet resistance is that the auditee feels unheard. Their explanation was not in the report, or it was mentioned and dismissed.

The research on persuasion suggests a better approach. Mike Allen's 1991 meta-analysis compared one-sided messages with two-sided ones. Messages that raised the opposing view and then answered it were more persuasive than one-sided messages; messages that raised the opposing view and left it unanswered were less persuasive than one-sided messages that left it out.1

For an audit finding, that means writing management's view into the presentation fairly, in their terms, and then responding to it: "Management's view is that the manual check catches these errors. We tested the manual check on 40 transactions and it caught 3 of the 9 errors in the sample." The auditee hears that they were listened to, and also why the finding stands.

The closing meeting

Hold the closing meeting before the report is final, so nothing in the report surprises the auditee. Walk through each finding, listen to their response, correct anything that is factually wrong, and agree actions with owners and dates. A closing meeting where the auditee helps shape the actions produces actions that get done.

Reporting to the audit committee

Audit committees have limited time and need to know where the real risks are. Present:

  1. An overall opinion on the areas audited.
  2. The few findings that matter most, with their risk and management's response.
  3. Overdue actions, especially high-risk ones, with the reason they are late.
  4. Themes across audits: the same control failing in several places is more important than any single finding.

Resist presenting every finding. The committee needs to see what would keep them up at night.

Following up on actions

When agreed actions are not done, the follow-up presentation is uncomfortable. Present it factually: the action, the date agreed, the current status, the reason given, and the risk while it remains open. Overdue actions presented consistently and without drama get resolved; ones that are allowed to slip quietly teach everyone that audit actions are optional.

The questions you will be asked

Auditees often ask "Is this really a significant issue?", "Did you test enough to be sure?" and "Why are we being held to a standard other teams aren't?" Have answers ready: the risk in money or exposure, the sample and method, and, if it is true, a note that the same finding has been raised elsewhere.

For explaining numbers out loud under questioning, see public speaking tips for accounting managers, and for the research on raising and answering the other side, every good talk is secretly an argument.

References

  1. Allen, M. (1991). Meta‐analysis comparing the persuasiveness of one‐sided and two‐sided messages. Western Journal of Speech Communication, 55(4), 390–404. https://doi.org/10.1080/10570319109374395