Presentation Tips for Compensation and Benefits Managers

By Daniel Harper · Career & Business

How should a compensation and benefits manager present pay decisions? Explain the process before the outcome: how pay is set, what is compared, who decides. When people get less than they hoped, the fairness of the process is most of what they judge. Brief managers first, give them the words and the data, and present benefits changes with what each person gains and loses, in plain numbers.

Compensation and benefits managers present the decisions that affect people most directly: the annual pay review, a new pay framework, a change to the pension or health plan, the explanation of why someone's grade is what it is. Almost every one of these leaves someone disappointed. How the presentation is handled decides whether disappointment turns into distrust.

Process first, outcome second

When people receive an unfavourable outcome, they look hard at how it was reached. Joel Brockner and Batia Wiesenfeld's review of 45 samples found that the fairness of the procedure had a stronger relationship with people's reactions precisely when the outcome was unfavourable.1 When the news is good, people care less how the decision was made. When it is not, the process is what they have.

For a pay presentation, that means explaining the framework before the numbers:

  • How pay is set: what market data is used, how roles are grouped, how performance affects increases.
  • Who decides, and what checks exist for consistency and fairness.
  • What an employee can do if they think a decision is wrong.

A pay review presented this way is far easier to accept than one presented as a set of numbers handed down.

Brief managers first

Most employees hear about their pay from their manager, not from the compensation team. If managers do not understand the framework, they will either say "it came from HR" (which undermines them and the decision) or explain it wrongly. Before any pay communication goes out:

  • Walk managers through the framework and the decisions for their team.
  • Give them the words: a short script for the conversation, and answers to the questions they will be asked.
  • Give them the data they need to explain an individual decision.

Presenting a benefits change

Benefits changes, such as a new pension contribution structure or a change of health insurer, are often confusing. Make them concrete. Show what changes, in money, for a few typical employees: someone early in their career, someone with a family, someone close to retirement. People understand "you will pay $14 more a month and your deductible falls by $500" far better than a table of plan features.

Say plainly who gains and who loses. If some people are worse off, acknowledge it and say why the change is being made. Presenting a change as good for everyone when it is not destroys trust quickly.

When an employee asks for an explanation

Sometimes the compensation team explains a decision directly to an employee who has challenged it. Listen first: often the complaint is about one comparison the person has heard about. Then explain the framework, what data was used for their role, and how their position was decided. If there was a mistake, say so and correct it. If there was not, say clearly what would change their pay in future, such as a new role, a market change or performance at a given level.

Presenting to leadership

When you present pay proposals to leadership, show the cost, the market position before and after, the effect on any pay gaps you track, and the risks: attrition in roles where the company is paying below market, or budget pressure where it is above.

Questions you will be asked

Employees will ask "How does my pay compare?", "Why did I get less than last year?" and "Who decided this?" Managers will ask how to handle someone who threatens to leave. Prepare answers, and be clear about what can and cannot be shared, and why.

For explaining unwelcome decisions more generally, see presentation tips for product development managers, and for the HR side of these roles in an interview, behavioral interview questions for human resources managers.

References

  1. Brockner, J., & Wiesenfeld, B. M. (1996). An integrative framework for explaining reactions to decisions: interactive effects of outcomes and procedures. Psychological Bulletin, 120(2), 189–208. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.120.2.189